View topic - The overdiagnosis of Bipolar Disorder

Poot wrote:I'm not discounting the fact that there are people who legitimately have bipolar disorder. I know it exists. I've met a few people who actually have it.

What I'm saying is, this has become a "popular" disorder for psychiatrists to diagnose. It has grown to the rate of the AD(H)D epidemic, where everyone can get diagnosed with this now when they don't actually have it.

You see, in America we eat like crap. There's no denying it. We consume massive amounts of sugar, carbs, and caffeine...and people don't take in to consideration the negative effects that these things have on the body. Caffeine causes irritability. Carbs and sugar cause severe spikes in mood followed by falls in mood. Pretty much, it can mimic bipolar disorder.

So why do you think that people are so quick to assume they have a mental illness and take a pill for something they don't actually have...which ruins their health further...rather than just correcting their diet and getting some exercise?


Haha people love to self diagnos themselves as bipolar I have about 6 people at the high school went to to that claimed they were bipolar, acted like depressed emos and had no life. I know very well they weren't bipolar as I've met someone who is. They were merely crying out for attention. If someone truly has a disorder and isn't an attention seeking idiot, then I respect them. But it annoys the hell out of me when people pretend.
Post by Flying Frogs » Tue Nov 08, 2011 5:14 pm
I think the OP had some great points...
And I agree with them completely. It seems that psychiatrists like to give diagnostics mostly just to get their clients to purchase medications, or to continue sessions. Thus, over-diagnostics.

Since I was a kid, I've been diagnosed with a ton of incorrect, weird, and unlikely things, and go figure, they were all "incurable" unless I was on medication. It took years with being with the same therapist and psychologist before I finally got diagnosed with a personality disorder.

At the same time, I think psychiatrists can be swayed based on what their clients say, or feel. So, if their client says, "I think I have bipolar disorder" and they show some legitimate symptoms, they'll be more likely to diagnose them with bipolar. I mean, I think diet does play a huge role on a person's mental health... but I don't think it's such a huge role that it could create or "cure" a mental imbalance. I think it can help to heal from it, but it's definitely not the sole key to curing, or creating any mental illness.
Post by Rawiyah » Tue Nov 08, 2011 7:58 pm

I have noticed this too, that all kinds of celebrities are suddenly being diagnosed as bipolar. I don't know what to think but it does seem a bit suspicious to me as well.
Post by Lady Heather » Wed Nov 09, 2011 1:10 am
I know, when I was tested I was diagnosed with being borderline bi polar.

>.>

I'm like I don't have mood swings, I feel when I am angry or what ever I have a legit reason to be.

I think just because I have a family history of it that they were quick to say ok this is it >.>

My therapist and psychologist have never suggested Bi polar. I know I have ptsd, which caused a but load of problems but I don't think I'm Bi polar. Also I have pmdd which causes mood swings, which I was just recently diagnosed with.

My mum is Text book, and I had a bio teacher in High school who was txt book bi polar. So I know what it is like and I don't come close.
Post by princejekyll » Thu Nov 10, 2011 4:23 pm

D:I'm Jekyll:D

Click My face for quest
1/4 burgundy spell

✫Nowadays it`s so easy to diagnose.
And another thing.
I see people who diagnose themselves with Bipolar disorder.
It is really annoying.
Post by Beasley. » Sun Nov 20, 2011 3:00 pm


Byee !
I've heard people say they're bipolar when they didn't even know what it meant <_<

My mom says she doesn't care how bipolar I am, I still need to keep a handle on my emotions. It's like one minute I'm completely calm and happy the next minute I'm screaming and crying and I really hate it. It really isn't anything to talk about faking. I think about it everyday and how it affects those around me. My mom doesn't even trust me with my sister anymore v.v

I know I'm still developing and hopefully my teen hormones will chill the hell out. I keep to myself hoping nothing bad will happen. I've been known to have complete meltdowns.

I don't trust that psychiatrist I went to though >_> he seemed...slow -_- But it is believable. My family does have a history of...very lovely behaviors :3
Post by Ĵɛlly βɛαns » Sat Nov 26, 2011 1:52 am

I always thought bipolar was pretty rare and was more of going inter hypermania then into depression over the course of a couple days rather than a couple hours. And hypermania is less common than depression where people go on an absolute high and can even do stupid things at times like being drunk.

I have severe mood swings from really hyperactive to depressed and get urges to do things I wouldn't normally do but since it happens within a couple of hours, but it doesn't mean I'm bipolar. lol

The situation over here in Australia seems to be the opposite. I was going through a phase where I was suicidal and had severe urges to mutilate myself (not depressive in those times but just strong urges). The doctors all told me that I just had anxiety and needed to chill out, which I was considering it was my holiday . oops
Post by Thalassaemia » Sat Nov 26, 2011 2:51 pm


DeviantArt Gallery
I completely agree with this.
Im in college for Substance Abuse Counseling, but being that a lot of addicts are really just self medicating themselves we have to study a lot of mental illnesses as well.
The only way a doctor can bill insurance is if they have a diagnosis so I think thats one reason why they are so quick to slap a label on it and give you meds. I also think people just want quick results, so they advocate pills instead of therapy or something more long term.
Im not saying there arnt people out there who have bipolar, and that the meds dont help, I just think its getting a little out of hand, same with the add/adhd.
Post by Twisty » Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:16 pm


Glitch Please.
Click Pic for Art Shop


Buying/Selling
A lot of people have a bad month or two and so they think they are either depressed or have bi-polar disorder. It's over diagnosed because the tests the do are inaccurate. My friend comes to me every month during her period thinking she's bi-polar and once she even told me that she was diagnosed but couldn't get the medicine. If she was truly diagnosed they wouldn't let her leave the doctor's office without the medicine. So that's another thing, people go around saying they have it just to give a reason for why there hormones and emotions are wonky for a little while.
Post by ℬarbie » Thu Dec 01, 2011 6:30 am


If I poof, it's because I got lost o.0

The solution isn't pointing the finger at people and shaming them for their problems. The solution lies in making healthy options affordable for everyone. About the only one of those things that can be instantly solved with a cheaper option is substituting soda with tap water. And that's only if you don't suffer any ill effects from drinking chlorine.


There you go, that's the issue. You can shove it in other people's faces all you want with simply just 'eat healthy,' but the fact is: People can't afford it. It's nice when you can afford to eat healthy, though. I can afford eating right but, doesn't mean everything else can unless you're completely blind to this world, you'd realize that. Do a bit of research on how much households struggle everyday just to put a meal on the table. Is no food really better then junk/unhealthy food? I didn't think so.

Needless to say, it's more so Doctor's fault with these type of things. They diagnose, give pills and off their way. People put trust into their Doctors, so when their Doctors are telling them they have to take these pills to get better, they will find a way to afford them, that's how it is.
Post by the beatles. » Sat Dec 03, 2011 7:28 pm
I know when i was in high school just a few years ago my mom made me see one of those doctors that persibe it cant think of what it is called but she put me on medication for bipolar and depression so she had some form of controlling me. and the only reason why they said that i had it is becuase they said they did tests on me to see what i was like in school. when i was in class i was quite and i only talked to my friends when ever i had a class with them or i would talk to the teacher a little bit and i was mainly quite and when i was at home i was always in my room and never socialized with my mom and my step dad. but the medication i was on made me feel worse than what i was. maybe 8 to 9 months i ago before i became an apostolic penacotles i was depressed and i wanted to kill myself mainly because i didn't really have friends after i moved away from my mom and i didn't know where my life was going then in july i went to church camp my friends from church drug me along and i got filled with the holly ghost and i have been happy ever since. so i think it is over diagnosed. because one the sugar that can mimic it and people say loners and the quite people like me that don't talk to people and are with drawn are bi polar when the are not. and people that see the comercials for the medication on tv think i am depressed so i have that disorder so they get medication for it when they don't need it my mom does this. the reason why we do this is because this is america and we eat that stuff up like candy
Post by Slaying Reaper » Sat Dec 03, 2011 10:11 pm

We are the light to reach this world
We are the salt preserving souls
Let´s show them the love that we´ve received now

We are, we are in desperation
We need to reach this generation
We are speaking louder than before
I think another reason bipolar disorder is overly diagnosed is because the tests they give you are your own personal interpretations of yourself. Asking someone "on a scale of 1-10 how often would you say you are depressed?" gives them the power to say whatever they want for the answer. My brother who is not depressed was forced to go to a psychiatrist because his school suspected he had some mental problems. He knew that if the psychiatrists felt they had helped the situation, he would get to leave so he led them to believe he was depressed. They prescribed him anti-depressants and he got to leave. He played the system! Before he started doing that, they thought he was suffering from antisocial personality disorder. (I think they were right on there)

Another thing I think is overly diagnosed is Autism!
Post by promised_forever » Sun Dec 04, 2011 12:03 am
27 Posts • Page 2 of 2

 
Users browsing this topic: and 1 guests